Top Scotty McCreery Songs From American Idol: A Look Back At His Best Performances

As Scotty McCreery prepares to release his new album 'Clear as Day' next month, let's take a moment to look back on the top Scotty McCreery songs from American Idol that put the winner into our homes and hearts. He sang over two dozen songs during his four months on television, but we’ve paired it down to the top 10 songs from season 10.

All 10 of these songs, except his duet with Tim McGraw, were competition songs -- meaning they counted for or against him. In actuality, his frequent duets with Lauren Alaina probably helped his chances as much as any song he sang individually, but since it is an individual singer's reality show we tried to keep the list to only the songs that mattered. Be sure to share your favorite McCreery moments in the feedback section below.

• Where Were You (When the World Stopped Turning)
• I Cross My Heart
• Are You Gonna Kiss Me or Not
• The River
• Letters From Home
• You've Got a Friend
• Live Like You Were Dying
• That's All Right
• Your Man
• Gone

Where Were You (When the World Stopped Turning), Alan Jackson

This performance marked a significant moment as it coincided with the 10th anniversary of the September 11 tragedy. The emotional weight of the song was palpable, and although McCreery was only 7-years-old when the Twin Towers fell, he attempted to make the song his own by hitting higher notes. It was a commendable effort, but many felt there were stronger performances in the competition.

I Cross My Heart, George Strait

During season 10, McCreery occasionally opted for safe choices instead of tackling challenging themes. Choosing a song from the 'Pure Country' soundtrack, he played it safe and avoided taking risks that could have showcased his versatility. This status quo performance did not significantly impact his fan base but kept him in the competition.

Are You Gonna Kiss Me or Not, Thompson Square

This song was a surprising choice, as it was relatively new at the time. Coach Jimmy Iovine's selection raised eyebrows, but McCreery made the most of the moment by using his acoustic guitar. This pivotal performance helped him secure a spot in the final two, even if it wasn't a song he would have chosen himself.

The River, Garth Brooks

Randy Jackson's enthusiastic encouragement, telling McCreery to "don't change it!", spoke volumes about this performance. At this point, McCreery was still finding his footing, but he began to develop a strong stage presence. His rendition of Garth Brooks' classic solidified his identity as a country singer.

Letters From Home, John Michael Montgomery

McCreery took some artistic liberties with this heartfelt song, which resonated deeply with families of military members. His performance was touching, though it was only a glimpse of his potential. This early in the competition, it was essential for him to prove his worth against other contestants, making this performance significant for his growth.

You've Got a Friend, Carole King

Familiarity with Carole King's music allowed McCreery to deliver a solid performance of this classic. The song held personal significance for him, having been a part of a youth retreat in the past. His knowledge of the lyrics made this performance shine, showcasing his ability to connect with the audience.

Live Like You Were Dying, Tim McGraw

Joining Tim McGraw onstage was a memorable moment for McCreery, with their chemistry evident throughout the performance. This song allowed him to show a deeper emotional range, something many 17-year-olds might struggle to convey. McGraw's presence undoubtedly added credibility to McCreery's performance.

That's All Right, Elvis Presley

In this performance, McCreery embraced his idols, channeling Elvis Presley with a smile and deep voice that captivated the audience. It was a turning point where he allowed his personality to shine through, marking the start of a more engaging stage presence. Judges and fans alike responded enthusiastically to his energetic rendition.

Your Man, Josh Turner

Despite being teased for his reliance on this song, McCreery's rendition of "Your Man" remained a standout in his repertoire. The song, which he auditioned with, was a strong entry that resonated with audiences. The repeated airings of his audition tape gave the impression that he relied too heavily on this song, but it truly showcased his vocal strengths.

Gone, Montgomery Gentry

McCreery's encore performance of "Gone" during the season finale highlighted his growth and enthusiasm. The judges remarked on the energy he brought to the stage, making it feel like a concert experience. This song has since become a highlight of the American Idols Live Tour, solidifying its place in McCreery's career.

What was your favorite Scotty McCreery song on American Idol? Do you agree with our list, or is there a performance that stood out to you more? Let us know!