Exploring Carly Pearce And Ashley McBryde's "Never Wanted To Be That Girl"

During "Never Wanted to Be That Girl," Carly Pearce and Ashley McBryde play two women who find out they're both in a committed relationship with the same man. This intriguing narrative, combined with their emotional performances, raises questions about relationships, fidelity, and the complexities involved. Listeners are encouraged to approach the lyrics with an open mind, as they delve into the storytelling aspect that resonates with many.

Pearce and McBryde teamed up with Shane McAnally to bring "Never Wanted to Be That Girl" to life. In an interview, Pearce highlighted how both artists felt this song would be perfect as a duet. The lyrics were crafted almost chronologically, which gives it a natural flow. However, while the writing process seemed seamless, it was not without its challenges.

“It was an odd one. We fought for it in some ways of trying to make that chorus stay the same and trying to make sure we got all the pieces right,” Pearce shared, referring to the creative journey behind the song. The anticipation surrounding the release of her album, 29: Written in Stone, adds to the excitement, as it features this captivating track.

Understanding the Story Behind the Song

The song opens with McBryde's vocals, setting the scene with relatable lyrics: “You helped me change a tire in the Citgo parking lot / You said we both could use a beer / I said, 'Hell, why not?'” This narrative draws listeners in, creating a vivid picture of the initial connection between the two women and the man they unknowingly share.

Pearce was envisioned as the "wife," while McBryde took on the role of the other woman. McBryde remarked, “I’m certainly not going to be the one to be out changing a tire and grab[ing] a beer. That felt more like Ashley, and my scenario felt more like me.” This division of roles adds depth to the storytelling, allowing each artist to showcase their perspective.

As the song progresses, Pearce’s verse unfolds a story of heartbreak and realization. She sings about the signs often ignored in relationships, emphasizing the importance of self-awareness. “I’ve heard about those women who didn’t have a clue,” she reflects, inviting listeners to empathize with the experiences portrayed.

The Emotional Journey of the Lyrics

Pearce and McBryde both believe that the story depicted in "Never Wanted to Be That Girl" resonates with many women. Pearce stated, “I think it’s a story that happens more times than people even want to admit.” This acknowledgment not only highlights the song's relatability but also reinforces the significance of female artists sharing their truths through music.

Written in late May or early June, just before Pearce returned to the studio, the song drew comparisons to the iconic "Does He Love You," by Reba McEntire and Linda Davis. However, Pearce emphasized that their intent was to carve out a unique narrative, different from the classic hit, which they deeply respect.

Through the choruses, the emotions conveyed range from sorrow to acceptance, with no animosity directed towards the other woman. The lyrics express a shared experience rather than blame, showcasing a mature perspective that Pearce acknowledges she couldn't have written earlier in her career. “I just hadn’t experienced life,” she says, reflecting on her growth as an artist.

Significance of the Release

"Never Wanted to Be That Girl" stands as the second single from Pearce's album, following her earlier hit "Next Girl." The album itself has garnered attention, with nominations for prestigious awards, further solidifying Pearce and McBryde's status in country music.

As the song resonates with listeners, it encapsulates the struggles many face in relationships, making it a poignant addition to the country music landscape. The collaboration between Pearce and McBryde not only reflects their individual artistry but also the power of women coming together to share their narratives.

Through "Never Wanted to Be That Girl," Carly Pearce and Ashley McBryde invite listeners to explore the complexities of love and heartbreak, creating a dialogue that many can relate to. Their powerful storytelling and emotive vocals ensure that the song will leave a lasting impact, encouraging audiences to reflect on their own experiences.

Key Takeaways