Carrie Underwood Joins American Idol: What To Expect From The New Judge

Carrie Underwood is joining the roster of American Idol judges early next year, and Luke Bryan already knows what to expect when she takes a seat at the table. During a chat with Taste of Country Nights, host Evan Paul asked Bryan whether he thinks his country music counterpart will be too soft or too kind with contestants. When Underwood competed on the show in 2005 — and ultimately won — the notoriously critical Simon Cowell was a judge.

Bryan notes that times have changed significantly since then. He explains, "We've all gotten a lot softer in that role as the show has evolved." He reminisces about the early days of American Idol, where the show's appeal was often due to the outrageous reactions of Cowell to less-than-stellar performances. Underwood's new role comes as she replaces Katy Perry, joining Bryan and Lionel Richie as judges.

According to Bryan, the show has shifted focus over the years, moving away from harsh critiques and towards nurturing budding talent. He believes Underwood will excel in this environment, stating, "I think Carrie will do a great job at that." He emphasizes the importance of maintaining a positive atmosphere where contestants feel supported, while also recognizing the need for constructive feedback when necessary.

Biography of Carrie Underwood

What Luke Bryan Thinks About Carrie as a Judge

Luke Bryan has a strong belief that Carrie Underwood will adapt well to her new role as a judge. He acknowledges the transformation of American Idol over the years, stating, "The show has gotten away from a lot of that, and more about lifting these kids up." Bryan insists that while the judges need to be kind, there are moments when tough love is necessary to prepare contestants for the music industry.

When asked if Underwood can be firm with contestants when needed, Bryan confidently replies, "I don't see why she wouldn't." He highlights her experience navigating the music business as a woman, noting that she has done so with both grace and a strong will. Underwood's ability to balance kindness with firmness will likely contribute to her effectiveness as a judge.

Underwood's Impact on the Show

Underwood's debut season as an American Idol judge is set to begin in spring 2025. As a former winner, her unique perspective will undoubtedly resonate with contestants aiming to make their mark in the industry. Bryan believes her journey from contestant to judge is a valuable asset in understanding the challenges these young performers face.

With Underwood’s extensive background in music and her positive approach, fans can anticipate a refreshing new dynamic on the show. This shift towards a more supportive environment aligns with Bryan’s vision of what the show has become over the years, making Underwood an ideal fit for the judging panel.

Evan Paul is the host of Taste of Country Nights, a syndicated radio show heard on more than 130 country radio stations nationwide, every night from 7PM to midnight. The radio show reaches over 21 million listeners per week. He plays the best new country music and interviews today's top stars, like Luke Combs, Morgan Wallen, Kenny Chesney, Miranda Lambert, Dan + Shay, Keith Urban, Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, Chris Stapleton, Lady A, + more!